Trump's "One America": English as the Official Language of the United States

On March 1, 2025, U.S. President Donald Trump signed an executive order designating English as the official language of the United States. This is a historic event, marking the first time in U.S. history that an official language has been designated at the federal level. However, it is important to note that while the executive order is currently in effect, it has not yet been officially codified through the legislative process. This decision has had a significant impact on American society, sparking in-depth discussions on national identity, diversity, and global leadership.

White House Presidential Actions

Language and National Identity: Historical Lessons

The impact of language on the formation of a nation's identity is significant. One historical example to understand this is the language suppression policies implemented by Japan in Korea during the period of Japanese colonial rule. Japan banned the use of Korean and enforced the use of Japanese to weaken the Korean national identity and consolidate its colonial rule. This demonstrates that language is more than just a tool for communication; it is a key element of cultural identity and national cohesion. Of course, there is a fundamental difference between this and the situation in the United States. The pursuit of English as the official language in the U.S. is not a coercive assimilation policy, but rather a policy decision made in consideration of realizing a unified vision of "One America," ensuring smooth communication among citizens, and improving administrative efficiency. However, through this example, we can more easily understand the impact language has on national identity.

English as the Official Language of the United States: Background and Purpose

Attempts by the United States to designate English as its official language are not new. However, there have been several reasons why such a decision has not been made at the federal level until now.

*Historical Background: The United States is a nation built by diverse immigrants, and linguistic diversity has existed since its founding. The Founding Fathers intentionally did not designate an official language.
*Multiculturalism and Inclusivity: The United States has traditionally been considered a "melting pot" or "salad bowl" society, and recognizing and embracing diverse cultures and languages has been considered an American value.
*Pragmatic Approach: Because English has been used as the de facto official language, there has not been a strong felt need to legally formalize it.
*Political Controversy: Designating an official language has often been a politically sensitive issue, with concerns and opposition regarding the infringement of the rights of minority language speakers.
*Constitutional Considerations: Freedom of language is related to freedom of expression, so there has been potential for constitutional controversy.

However, President Trump's executive order represents a departure from this traditional approach and proposes a new direction. The main objectives of this policy are as follows:

*Strengthening National Unity: To promote communication and understanding among citizens through a common language and strengthen national identity.
*Increasing Government Efficiency: To increase administrative efficiency by standardizing all official documents and services in English and reduce the costs associated with providing multilingual services.
*Promoting Immigrant Integration: To encourage English learning to promote the social integration and economic participation of immigrants.
*Strengthening Global Competitiveness: To reflect the reality that English serves as an international lingua franca and enhance America's global leadership.

Opinions of Supporters and Opponents

This policy has sparked controversy within American society. It has received strong support, particularly from conservatives, for the following reasons:

*Maintaining Traditional Values: They view English as the traditional language of the United States and have a strong desire to preserve it.
*Emphasis on National Unity: They believe that using a single language will help strengthen national unity and social cohesion.
*Immigrant Assimilation Policy: They argue that immigrants should learn English and quickly assimilate into American society.
*Reducing Government Costs: They argue that it will reduce government spending on providing multilingual services.
*Political Ideology: They support the official use of English in connection with political ideologies such as "America First" or "patriotism."

On the other hand, liberals and minority language communities have expressed strong concerns and opposition to this policy. Their arguments are as follows:

*Erosion of Diversity: They are concerned that it could undermine the cultural and linguistic diversity of the United States.
*Infringement of Minority Rights: They believe that the rights of those whose native language is not English may be violated.
*Concerns about Discrimination: They warn that discrimination based on language could increase.
*Constitutional Issues: They argue that the freedom to choose a language could violate the freedom of expression guaranteed by the Constitution.
*Damage to Global Image: They are concerned that it could damage America's image as a "land of the free."

America's Decision in a Global Context

While some argue that America's policy of making English the official language is a strategy to strengthen its global leadership, others counter that it could weaken America's soft power. Multinational organizations such as the European Union (EU) maintain strong political and economic influence while recognizing diverse languages. Furthermore, recognizing multiple languages can provide greater flexibility in international cooperation and diplomacy. As a nation that wields influence across the globe, America's multicultural identity has been a key component of its global leadership. Designating English as the official language could potentially harm this strength and have a negative impact on global businesses and international exchanges. Therefore, careful analysis is needed to determine what impact this policy will have on America's international standing in the long term.

America's Future and Global Leadership

America's decision to make English the official language goes beyond a simple change in language policy; it raises fundamental questions about America's national identity, social integration, and global leadership. This can be seen as a strategic choice to address internal and external challenges facing the United States.
Language is more than just a tool for communication; it is a powerful means of shaping national identity and strengthening social cohesion. While the U.S. has long pursued values of respecting diversity and freedom, this has led to several problems, such as linguistic fragmentation, social isolation, and ambiguity in national identity. The debate over bilingual education in public schools, increased translation costs in providing government services, and delays in the social integration of immigrant communities are examples of this.
President Trump's executive order designating English as the official language can be considered a significant attempt to address these issues and achieve the vision of "One America." A unified language policy can increase the efficiency of government administration, reduce communication barriers between citizens, and strengthen national cohesion. In particular, encouraging English learning among immigrants can provide them with opportunities to more easily integrate into American society and the economy.
However, it remains to be seen whether this policy will actually contribute to creating "One America" or whether it will exacerbate social divisions. We must also pay attention to how this decision will affect America's global image and soft power.
Ultimately, America's decision can be seen as an attempt to redefine its identity and leadership in a changing global environment. It aims to strengthen national unity through a common language, thereby responding more effectively to domestic issues while also strengthening its leadership on the international stage. Finding the right balance between respecting diversity and achieving national unity will be a challenge for America, and the world is watching to see how America overcomes this challenge and finds a new equilibrium.